Newest Created Pets



Rapscallion the
Halloween Makoat

Owner: Fishbone



Lightfinder the
White Traptur

Owner: tstske



Langdon the
Love Ridix

Owner: Yoda







Welcome to the IcePets Forums!

For every reply or new topic you create you will receive 100 IcePoints!
Gold Accounts also receive 1 IC for their first 5 posts each day. More Info


Boards Home » Voting Booth
» Should we replace 100% Trophies

LOCKED
(You cannot reply to this topic)
« First · « Prev ·  (of 5)  · Next » · Last »

Replace 100% trophies?
Agree, Yes  25% 25 votes
Agree, No  61% 62 votes
Disagree, Yes  1% 1 vote
Disagree, No  2% 2 votes
Other  11% 11 votes


Skill



Posts: 760
Avatars: 79/206
Male



    15th of Aug '12 @ 2:45 PM Voted for Agree, No


I would like this.



Report Post

tilas



Posts: 942
Avatars: 105/206
Female



    15th of Aug '12 @ 2:54 PM Voted for Agree, No


I agree with this. I think it needs to be revamped. Some trophies are quickly becoming borderline impossible, so it would be nice to at least have a trophy for effort.



Report Post

    15th of Aug '12 @ 2:59 PM Voted for Other


To make my last post more clear

YES revamp it but still keep the 100% collection trophy when a perso ACTUALLY HAS 100% even with the new items released
If they don't have 100% with the new items in the collection downgrade the trophy to the next highest one.
When they reach 100% again, upgrade the trophy to 100%.
That way there's still a trophy for having a complete collection with new items released

Always buying discounted stamps not yet in my collection!
Currently 117/119

Currently buying: Bark Stamp & White Chocolate Stamp




Report Post
iLucas



Posts: 1204
Avatars: 86/206
Male




laurey



Posts: 881
Avatars: 66/206
Female



    15th of Aug '12 @ 3:05 PM Voted for Agree, No


Posted by iLucas


To make my last post more clear

YES revamp it but still keep the 100% collection trophy when a perso ACTUALLY HAS 100% even with the new items released
If they don't have 100% with the new items in the collection downgrade the trophy to the next highest one.
When they reach 100% again, upgrade the trophy to 100%.
That way there's still a trophy for having a complete collection with new items released

I support this idea actually smile_yes.gif
It would be nice to still have a 100% trophy for those who have earned it, but make the other trophies too.








Report Post

Tokcando



Posts: 3263
Avatars: 125/206
Male



    15th of Aug '12 @ 3:10 PM Voted for Agree, Yes


Posted by iLucas


To make my last post more clear

YES revamp it but still keep the 100% collection trophy when a perso ACTUALLY HAS 100% even with the new items released
If they don't have 100% with the new items in the collection downgrade the trophy to the next highest one.
When they reach 100% again, upgrade the trophy to 100%.
That way there's still a trophy for having a complete collection with new items released


I agree, because I just got the stamp trophy today smile_tongue.gif



Report Post

    15th of Aug '12 @ 3:10 PM Voted for Other


Like honestly when I get the last 4 stamps for my collection and I end up not getting a 100% trophy I'll be pissed.
Cause I assume the highestt "numbered" trophy would be 100 stamps or 105 stamps
If I have 108/108 I don't want a 100 stamps trophy, I want a 100% trophy

Always buying discounted stamps not yet in my collection!
Currently 117/119

Currently buying: Bark Stamp & White Chocolate Stamp




Report Post
iLucas



Posts: 1204
Avatars: 86/206
Male




lunnabell



Posts: 15
Avatars: 10/206
Female



    15th of Aug '12 @ 3:21 PM Voted for Agree, No


=3



Report Post

zolosteel



Posts: 21
Avatars: 5/206
Male



    15th of Aug '12 @ 3:24 PM Hasnt voted yet!


smile_yes.gif

Signature


Report Post

    15th of Aug '12 @ 3:25 PM Voted for Agree, Yes


no i think it fine the way it is

Signature


Report Post
tinkrr



Posts: 41
Avatars: 28/206
Female




lunnabell



Posts: 15
Avatars: 10/206
Female



    15th of Aug '12 @ 3:33 PM Voted for Agree, No


My vote didnt show up the first time.
I think if we replace the trophies more pepole would want to win one.



Report Post

    15th of Aug '12 @ 3:37 PM Voted for Agree, No


Definitely, yes smile_happy.gif I think it's more fair for everyone.

& we ripped up the ending, and the rules, and destiny, leaving nothing but freedom and choice.


Report Post
Nyssa



Posts: 5487
Avatars: 135/206
Female




Fiesty



Posts: 11
Avatars: 13/206
Male



    15th of Aug '12 @ 3:44 PM Voted for Agree, No


i have no trophies

Signature


Report Post

Draicheek



Posts: 107
Avatars: 42/206
Male



    15th of Aug '12 @ 4:02 PM Voted for Agree, No


I think it's a great idea. Having different levels of trophies shows status and progress.

People say having a "25, 50" stamp trophy would be too easy, but much like the dragon statue trophies, everyone would know that those trophies are easy to get, so it isn't like it's unfair and impressive.

But at the same time, it encourages new users to stay active because they are already on there way to achievement. All in all I think it's a very good idea.smile_yes.gif



Report Post

    15th of Aug '12 @ 4:13 PM Voted for Agree, No


I would prefer a better system, that way older users would not have an advantage in obtaining the trophies.



Report Post
Orion



Posts: 254
Avatars: 18/206
Female




    15th of Aug '12 @ 4:26 PM Voted for Agree, No


Wow, Great Idea! I want trophies so I agree.smile_happy.gif



Really want: Pet slot key, pet name changer, custom avatar


Report Post
seismitoad



Posts: 1142
Avatars: 57/206
Male




Zanthia



Posts: 1276
Avatars: 100/206
Female



    15th of Aug '12 @ 4:36 PM Voted for Agree, No


I think they do need to be reworked. I would be happy to see a system something like this:

100% Gold Trophy
90% Silver Trophy
80% Bronze Trophy

for the collections that are currently using the 100% method. And if you drop below the % you get the next level down or have the trophy removed if below 80%.

It is nice to have leaderboards, but we already have that for beauty and books. And I would like to see some of our collections not based off of how we rank up against other players, but just how we rank up against our own collections... if that makes sense. I think it's good to have a balance between the two styles of trophy systems. I would be very disappointed to see the gourmet and stamps be based off of the 1 or 2 item difference that the beauty and books are. I think the % gives a fairer overall analysis of a player's dedication toward their collection.

- - * Brynn * - - - - - - - * Faun * - - - - - - - - * Darm * - - - - - - - * Brandywine * - -



Report Post

hiskey



Posts: 974
Avatars: 51/206
Male



    15th of Aug '12 @ 4:59 PM Voted for Agree, No


voted smile_ninja.gif



Report Post

purplepetal



Posts: 22
Avatars: 21/206
Female



    15th of Aug '12 @ 5:32 PM Voted for Agree, No


I think this is an excellent idea! It would make people really feel like they're making progress with their collections while getting a shiny new trophy.



Signature


Report Post

    15th of Aug '12 @ 6:14 PM Voted for Agree, No




smile_yes.gif






ଘ(ᐢ ິ•ᆺ ິ•ᐢ)ଓ


Report Post
Soot



Posts: 2735
Avatars: 137/206
Female




Static



Posts: 1458
Avatars: 73/206
Male



    15th of Aug '12 @ 8:39 PM Voted for Disagree, Yes


I think It needs to be changed, but honestly I think the incremental idea is just as bad as the 100% one. xP Not only will it become increasingly cheap with time, but it also defeats the original purpose of these trophies; A reward for getting your collection complete as possible. I see where you're coming from, but i don't see how making them worthless is preferable.

As the "funder" of these trophies, I realize the initial idea wasn't really that great, which is why I made that board in the first place, and why I've offered to fund the re-coding for a collections leaderboard for the trophies to be repurposed to (although It looks like Nate ignored my message about that xP).

Anyway, A leaderboard is what this issue needs. That way we could see our stats compared to other users, and it would maintain itself as more stamps are released... a percent completion or incremental completion trophy both pose the same problems.

~ Icepets Neighborhood Frostitute! ~


Report Post

Naila



Posts: 110
Avatars: 64/206
Female



    16th of Aug '12 @ 1:27 AM Voted for Agree, No


I think that would be the best!



Report Post

    16th of Aug '12 @ 2:24 AM Voted for Agree, No


smile_yes.gif

I also think having leaderboards is a v good idea smile_happy.gif



Report Post
Misty



Posts: 67
Avatars: 29/206
Female




Naila



Posts: 110
Avatars: 64/206
Female



    16th of Aug '12 @ 6:45 AM Voted for Agree, No


Good idea and the trophys should change colors as you get a higher %



Report Post

Angels4Ever



Posts: 3695
Avatars: 82/206
Female



    16th of Aug '12 @ 11:50 AM Voted for Agree, No


I like this system idea.smile_grin.gif




Report Post

Jobie



Posts: 303
Avatars: 48/206
Female



    16th of Aug '12 @ 5:15 PM Voted for Agree, No


I think it is a good idea. smile_happy.gif



Report Post


LOCKED
(You cannot reply to this topic)
« First · « Prev ·  (of 5)  · Next » · Last »



© Copyright IcePets.Com (Andrew Judd) 2009-2018. All Rights Reserved.
Version: 1.16.7.11 - Latest Deploy: 2018-10-15 18:34:05 IST


Link to Us · Staff · IcePets Stats · Help & Support · Terms & Conditions · Privacy Policy · Vote on VPD